Deli, Cheese & Salt

Amish Butter

Deli & Cheese

Amish-made butter ... there is no better! We carry Amish butter in our new Roscoe Village store from Amish butter makers here in the heart of Ohio Amish country.  Our roll butter is actually rolled by hand and wrapped in wax paper, now that's fresh!

Lightly salted or sweet, all-natural Amish Butter is a great addition to any recipe.  Add lots of it to make your simple mashed potatoes magnificent, or smear it on a toasted bagel or English muffin -- or best of all on homemade bread fresh from the oven.

A note from our Chef: 
For great tips and new ways to use Amish butter in your recipes, subscribe to our official store newsletter at the bottom of this page

Cheese Spreads

Deli & Cheese

We have a great selection of cheese spreads in our Roscoe Village Deli.  Our signature spreads include Dried Beef, Popeye's Olive, Pizza, Lemon Chiffon and more than 2 dozen other offerings that are rotated each week.  All of our signature spreads are made in-house by our Chef. 

We also carry a variety of spreads prepared by Walnut Creek Foods, all are made by the Amish of Holmes County, Ohio.  Try our spreads for your next party or just a late night snack.  They go well with any of our gourmet crackers, flatbreads and wafers.  Make sure to try a free sample on your next visit to Roscoe Village.

Medbery Marketplace
Open Daily 10-6
(740) 291-8000

Local Amish and Artisan Cheeses

Deli & Cheese

Holy cow, goat and buffalo... we are obsessed with cheese!

To assemble our wonderful assortment of cheeses we personally visit farms, dairies and cheese houses locally and around the world.  From small artisan cheese makers to large-scale Amish cheese producers we select a blend of New and Old World tastes just for Medbery Marketplace.

You Shop, We Slice
When you visit Medbery Marketplace you can have any cheese cut to order, sliced, cubed or designed into a beautiful party tray or gift basket.  And if you have other shopping to do in Roscoe Village, we'll slice and wrap your cheese

Also popular at Medbery Marketplace are our house made cheese spreads.  Favorite flavors include Popeye's Olive, Dried Beef and Pizza Spread.

We also offer a rotating variety of special flavors in both sweet and savory varieties including

  • Bacon
  • Bleu Cheese
  • Caramelized Onion
  • Cranberry Pecan
  • Peaches & Cream

These are great served with crackers, fresh veggies, vanilla wafers or graham crackers.

Our staff is here to help you select the perfect cheeses for your next event, find special recipes, find wine pairings or just something to snack on while you enjoy your visit to Roscoe Village.

Medbery Marketplace
(740) 291-8000
Open daily 10-6

Page 1 of 11